Idly Scribbling Rhymers: Poetry, Nation, and Community in 19th Century Japan


Robert J. TUCK (Université du Montana) donnera une conférence dans le cadre du séminaire du Centre Japon le 19 janvier 2017.

Discussions of Japanese literary modernity generally center on prose fiction rather than poetic genres, despite the important role poetry played in premodern Japanese literary culture. This paper, however, foregrounds two traditional poetic genres, kanshi (Sinitic poetry) and waka (modern tanka), and their role in Meiji-era (1867-1912) discourses of national literature (kokubungaku 国文学). As Meiji critics grappled with the creation and kokushi 国詩),” they also attempted in tandem to delineate the boundaries of national-poetic community. Exploring the poetry and critical writings of Meiji poets Masaoka Shiki 正岡子規 (1867-1902), Yosano Tekkan 与謝野鉄幹 (1873-1935), and kanshi poet Kokubu Seigai 国分青厓 (1857-1944), I highlight the fault lines and unstable boundaries of this national-poetic community, arguing that Japanese poetic modernity resisted the idea of nation and national-poetic community as synonymous. Tekkan, Seigai et al’s definitions of poetic community through exclusion and hierarchy – that is, who should not be a Japanese poet – complicate previous narratives of Meiji national literature that stress literary works as a focal point for visions of a cohesive national community.

In both kanshi and waka, political factionalism and notions of hierarchical masculinity were major fault lines in the national-poetic project. The 1870s popularity of quasi-erotic kanshi, the so-called “fragrant-style (Ch. xianglian ti, J. kōrentai香奩体),” elicited attacks on practitioners as immoral, feminized, and corrosive to ‘proper,’ vigorous masculinity. With “fragrant-style” poems popular within the Meiji government, poetic masculinity became entangled with political factionalism, anti-government poets (notably Seigai) conflating poetics and politics to paint fragrant-style poets as weak and unworthy to represent the nation. Similar anxieties over poetic effeminacy influenced Meiji discussions on waka; despite government promotion of waka as a national poetry, as in the imperially-convened New Year’s Poetry Party (utakai hajime 歌会始) and official Bureau of Poetry (Outadokoro 御歌所), much Meiji discourse on waka reflected concerns that the genre’s themes of wistful love made it insufficiently ‘manly.’ As Tekkan condemned the Outadokoro as effeminate and waka as “women’s literature,” here too fault lines of gender and political factionalism disrupted the seemingly natural adoption of waka as a national poetry.

Jeudi 19 janvier 2017 de 11h00 à 13h00
EHESS, Salle 7, 105 boulevard Raspail 75006 Paris


Citer ce billet
Yasuko D'Hulst (2017, 9 janvier). Idly Scribbling Rhymers: Poetry, Nation, and Community in 19th Century Japan. Carnets du Centre Japon. Consulté le 20 avril 2024, à l’adresse

Yasuko D'Hulst

Ingénieure d'études, Chargée de valorisation scientifique

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:

Yasuko D'Hulst

Ingénieure d'études, Chargée de valorisation scientifique

1 réponse

  1. 20/01/2017

    […] les fiches « Glossaire » et « bibliographie » de la séance du séminaire collectif du Centre Japon du 19 janvier 2017 animée par Robert J. TUCK (Université du […]

Rechercher dans OpenEdition Search

Vous allez être redirigé vers OpenEdition Search